How technology can help students with UCAS personal statements

Russell Stannard

Russell Stannard is a freelance trainer and conference speaker in ICT and Education. He has won 3 internationally recognized awards for his work in feedback and his www.teachertrainingvideos.com website, which is now visited by more than 350,000 users a year. He was previously a Principal Teaching fellow at the University of Westminster, where he won their ‘Excellence in Teaching and Learning’ award. He now works part-time at the University of Warwick as a Principal Teaching Fellow and is also a NILE associate trainer.

Follow @russell1955

Website: www.teachertrainingvideos.com Email This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
Originally published on 23rd September 2016 Originally published on 23rd September 2016

Personal statements are a vital part of the application process for university places. They are the one written piece of work that the universities staff dealing with applications will read. This is the chance for the students to make their voice heard, demonstrate what they are really about and what they are interested in. This can and does have an impact on admissions decisions. With more and more competition for places, they are playing an increasingly important role.

For many students, this will be one of the most important documents they have ever written. They are likely to need to write and rewrite the document several times, and in doing so learn about process writing. This is something they are hopefully already doing with their essay writing but in reality the process involved might be quite new to them. They often need a lot of support and feedback, and this can be very time-consuming. The ideas we outline below could help teachers with both the workload and time, but also the impact that their feedback and suggestions might have.

There are other places students can go for help, including a fair amount of help on the internet, but of course that tends to be very generic. You can certainly find some useful tips and guidance on writing a personal statement but it is quite likely that

  1. The students will want more personalised feedback.    
  2. Teachers will have their own personal tips and suggestions for making a good statement.

Screen capture technology is a very simple tool that simply records the screen of your computer as if a video camera was pointing at it. This means, for example, that a student can send you their work as a Word document, you can open it up onto your screen, mark the things you want to give feedback on, turn on the screen capture technology and record yourself correcting your student’s work. Everything you say and everything you do comes out in the video. You can then simply send the video to the student or upload it on a virtual learning environment, so that the students can access it. The students then have a live recording of you correcting their work. This idea generated enormous interest and resulted in a lot of media coverage. In 2009 the idea was included in the National Students’ Forum report submitted to the UK government. There is now research taking place all over the world.

This same idea can be used to provide help to students with their personal statements. We have been looking at how screen capture technology could be used to help students write their personal statements in a quick and effective way. We recently presented these ideas at a Heads of Sixth Form Conference in London; the feedback was hugely positive.

Idea one

Teachers often have their pet tips regarding personal statements. A teacher could open up a Microsoft Word document, write out their key tips, turn on the screen capture technology and record themselves talking over the key points. The video is instantly ready and can then be shared on YouTube so that students can access it online, or saved directly onto their computer and then shared on a virtual learning environment (like Moodle) or the school’s website. The video could even be emailed to the students.

One nice feature about sharing the video on YouTube is that it can be uploaded with just one click and can be set as unlisted too. This means it is not possible to search for the video on YouTube but can only be accessed if you have the link. Students can play and replay the video as often as they like. As one student said, it is like having their teacher in their pocket, and this can be very useful when they go to write their personal statements. They can play the video as a reminder of what to include and not to include in their personal statement.

Idea 2

It is very possible and very easy to give detailed feedback on a student’s personal statements using screen capture. A teacher can open up a student’s personal statement, mark the areas they want to give feedback on and then turn on the screen capture technology and simply go through the personal statement making comments as they move from point to point. Remember everything you say and do is recorded, so a teacher is able to provide a lot of detail in a pretty short video. The video can then be sent to the student. This can be very useful, as the student can replay the video as often as they like and work through their teacher’s comments. What is absolutely key here is that the students are encouraged to use the video to re-draft their statement.

Idea 3

An interesting way of using screen capture is to use it to give generic feedback to students rather than specific feedback to each individual student as we suggested in idea 2. Say for example you had 15 students’ personal statements to read. You could take notes on the general mistakes that the students have made and then write out the list in Microsoft Word or PowerPoint. You could then record yourself going through the points. Since most students often commit the same types of mistakes, it is likely that there will be something in the video for every student. Students can then watch the video and re-draft their personal statements based on your comments. Cognitively this is also a more interesting way of working with the video, since the students have to extract from the video the tips and comments that are relevant to them and then use them to re-draft their own personal statement.

Conclusions

  • Since the early work of using screen capture to provide feedback to students on their written work, there has been a number of research papers (see list below). Some of the key findings are:
  • Much more information can be conveyed in a short period of time.
  • Students like the fact they can play and replay the videos whenever they want.
  • Students like the visual and oral nature of the videos
  • They are easy to make and the generic videos can often end up saving teachers a lot of time.
  • The tips videos can be used time and time again. Once you have made one it can be used each year with different groups of students.
  • Students seem to find this form of feedback more engaging (though we are sure that if it was overused, this wouldn’t be the case).

Overall the research has been hugely positive, and we feel same will apply to students making personal statements. Being able to play the video and listen to the tips at the moment they actually write the statement, rather than remembering what the teacher had told them in class or making use of the notes, will be a huge help.

ICT is not always effectively used in schools. Often it is time-consuming and has little impact on teaching and learning. However we feel that in this context it really could save teachers time and impact on teaching and learning in a very positive way.

Recommended screen capture tools:

  • Screen cast- o-matic: A free tool that can be accessed from the internet. It also has a paid version too.
  • JING: A free tool that needs to be downloaded but can be a good introduction into using screen capture.
  • SnagIT: Our recommendation. It costs $30 (one off payment) but you get lots of features for your money and there is no restriction on length.

Research into screen capture feedback

Research into screen capture feedback in Norway
Research into screen capture feedback in Canada

Co-written by Steven Thomas

Do you use such technology in your work? Let us know below.

  • "Inspiring every school by sharing the latest ideas and innovations"

  • USEFUL LINKS

    About  
    Contact
    Privacy
    Terms
    Press

  • OFFICE ADDRESS

    Watergate Building
    Crane Wharf
    New Crane Street
    Chester
    CH1 4JE
    United Kingdom

  • GET IN TOUCH

    [email protected]
    +44 (0)1244 312 720

In order to make our website better for you, we use cookies!

Some firefox users may experience missing content, to fix this, click the shield in the top left and "disable tracking protection"